Reviews

Nainen joka varasti elämäni by Marian Keyes

ebkara's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Formulaic chick lit completely predictable and pretty annoying

uneven_shvm's review against another edition

Go to review page

slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

1.5

Wow, I just finished "The Women Who Stole My Life" by Marian Keyes, and I've gotta say, it was a struggle to get through. 500 pages of pure frustration? Check. Boring plot? Double check. 

Let's start with the characters - or should I say, the lack of character development. It felt like Keyes had a vague outline and just threw in whatever popped into her head. The result? A repetitive mess with a writing style that left a lot to be desired.

And don't even get me started on the main character. Without giving away spoilers, her decisions were so infuriating that I found myself wanting to throw the book across the room. How many times can you yell "Why?!" at a page before you lose your mind?

The plot conveniences were off the charts. I mean, seriously? How is any of this supposed to make sense? And backstory? What backstory? It's like Keyes forgot that readers might want to know, oh I don't know, why things are happening?

There were a few funny moments sprinkled throughout, but they were so few and far between that they definitely weren't worth slogging through the rest of the book for.

I'm feeling generous, so I'll give it two stars instead of one. There were a couple of redeeming qualities, but they were about as rare as finding a four-leaf clover in a concrete jungle.

In short, unless you're a masochist who enjoys literary torture, you might want to give this one a hard pass.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

lauramdb's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I really enjoyed this book. Marian Keyes has a fantastic talent for writing funny books about serious matters. Well worth a read.

mai1's review against another edition

Go to review page

The pacing was very slow and I couldn’t get into the rhythm of the story line however I understand it was not written for my age demographic 

punam's review against another edition

Go to review page

lighthearted reflective medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

cassiecat's review against another edition

Go to review page

lighthearted reflective slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Loveable characters? No

3.75

🎧3.75⭐️


Contemporary fiction with romance read by Aoife McMahon who is great, a favourite Irish narrator for me. 

The underlying premise of Stella’s story was brilliant. It’s very effective, and different, for me the best part of the story. I can’t mention it as it’s not disclosed in the blurb. 
But basically it’s a before and after time line. The before section held the most appeal for me, I thought that it was very cleverly done.As much as it’s got lots of humorous quips which I really enjoyed I felt this book dragged on too long. I’d have preferred a more condensed after section. I didn’t gel with any of the characters which in a lighter more feel good book I want to be really rooting for someone. 

This one wasn’t a favourite for me, but as I like her humour and writing style I’ll certainly be listening to more. 

booksbymonth's review against another edition

Go to review page

Confusing jumps. Didn't like the characters. 

emmacr2024's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Marian Keyes is finally back with her brand new novel ‘The Woman Who Stole My Life’. Any new release from Marian is always eagerly anticipated by her legions of fans and I am no exception. Marian was one of the first authors that got me into reading chicklit, although it goes far beyond that term and I think nowadays women’s fiction is a more suitable title for this genre.

I can remember many years ago being stuck in the Gaeltacht (an area where you go to learn Irish and stay with an Irish speaking family) for three weeks as part of my college course and Marian’s books got me through long boring days as they were always humorous with plenty of laugh out loud moments but also had a strong message at their centre. So I expected more great things with this new book despite reading some mixed reviews beforehand.

Having now read the book I can say I didn’t hate the book but yet neither did it have me fully engrossed, it just didn’t fully hit the mark for me and left me feeling underwhelmed. There were flashes of the brilliance we all know Marian is capable of but they were few and far between. Instead I was left wondering for the majority of the book ‘Where in God’s name is this going?'. Even the ending wasn’t all that great and I was left disappointed as I finished the last page.

This is a long book but despite that I was able to read it in three sittings, it didn’t feel a chore to read but it was missing the trademark Marian Keyes sparkle I have loved in the past. The main character is Stella Sweeney who we first meet as she has a car accident and crashes into Mannix Taylor - little does she realise karma has a role to play and she will encounter this man later in her life in the most unusual of circumstances. Fast forward and we discover Stella sitting at her desk attempting to write her second book with not much luck. I loved how Stella used Twitter as a distraction technique when inspiration wasn’t readily flowing because I think we all do that. I can even go as far to say this happens to me on a daily basis.

From here on the book jumps around an awful lot and not in a good way, I read this book on my Kindle and this normally doesn’t bother me but the formatting really wasn’t great and this took away from my enjoyment of reading about Stella and her troubles. One minute you were reading about Stella in the present where tantalising glimpses of her past were hinted at, then there were extracts from a book she had written called One Blink at a Time and then all of a sudden there were clues about time spent in New York. Very slowly all became clear but it was just too muddled up for my liking.

The first half of the book was well written and interesting as we discover Stella had developed an extremely rare illness called Guillan-Barre Syndrome an autoimmune disorder which attacks the central nervous system and had led to Stella spending long months in intensive care unable to move any part of her body or speak. The only thing she can do to communicate is blink.

I had never heard about this syndrome before but as we are with Stella every step of the way in hospital we feel for everything she is going through and how one minute your life can be going along OK and the next moment everything is turned upside down. Stella’s family were not the most supportive and I disliked her husband Ryan and son Jeffrey, her daughter Betsy seemed OK. But really Ryan was selfish, unsupportive and in the present day parts of the novel a total and utter weirdo. The only really nice, funny character was Stella’s dad -Bert he really should have been utilised more as he had a few good one liners. In hospital Mannix appears again as Stella’s neurologist and they develop a method of communication through blinking the alphabet. Mannix aids Stella’s recovery (it’s OK to mention this as it does happen quite early on in the book) and when she is released Ryan and Stella split leaving Stella to explore her feelings for Mannix.

I never got a convincing feeling that Stella was head over heels in love with Mannix, OK there were plenty of sex scenes which really didn’t need to be there and it was like they were just thrown in to spice up the book a bit and their relationship just developed way too fast. The flitting between the past and present continued throughout the book with sections titled him, her and me which being honest I didn’t know what they were about.

Having enjoyed reading about Stella’s time in hospital I found reading how she published her book and her time In New York was just boring and the mysterious Gilda was just an awful character whose role didn’t become clear until the end. But by then when I still had the feeling of where was this all going and what was the point of the story? Combined with the frankly ridiculous storyline Ryan had and the poor development of some of the characters and underutilisation of others, overall the book left me disappointed as it really didn’t live up to my hopes of another enthralling, engaging read from Marian. I’m sorry to say Marian Keyes may have just lost a fan but I’m sure this doesn’t matter as there will always be plenty of people queuing up to buy her books.

keen23's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I love Marian Keyes, but I don't love this book. It was OK, just not great. The son and the husband are such assholes that it makes the whole book drag on.

lolarose1234's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.75