maggieyangg's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

some parts were kinda boring but overall pretty good

lilyaronovitz's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This rating is solely based on my own enjoyment of this anthology, and in no way reflects the quality of writing or material in these essays. Of course, given that this is a collection of New Yorker essays, the writing in all of them is great, they are well-researched, and generally have a nice balance between anecdotal and more fact-heavy. However, I'm not sure if this book is necessarily meant to be read cover to cover. It's extremely long, informationally dense at times, and at least in my own opinion, not the most engaging or captivating anthology. I saw this written in another review and found that I agree: the target audience for this novel is a little bit unclear. It's not fully fact-based, so it's not the most succinctly informative for someone looking to learn more about global warming, but I'm not sure if the perspectives are unique enough to present enough particularly new or groundbreaking information for someone who already has a baseline knowledge about global warming to be really worthwhile for someone only moderately interested in the topic. Overall, the novel seemed to lack a pointed purpose, other than organizing various climate-change-oriented essays into one place. Granted, this gripe can also be interpreted the other way, as the stories were so different from each other that they all offered a take on a different aspect of climate change and the way it affects society.
There's no doubt these stories are important, and I liked the fact that they presented perspectives on climate change other than the ones we hear the most about, like just the rise in temperature, the depletion of the ozone, etc. I feel that most of my complaints could be avoided by reading this book in conjunction with maybe something more light-hearted or engaging, and so that you're not reading it from cover to cover all at once.

maddiey's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging informative reflective medium-paced

3.75

david_p1's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging informative reflective slow-paced

4.0


An engaging anthology of essays. Many in a reflective sense, issues we’ve know about for decades and yet these voices rang hollow in the halls of decision making. There are some glimmers of hope for potential actions and paths forward, though none without consequence, as we’ve crossed a few too many thresholds to completely avert climate change. Kolbert puts it bluntly in the afterword, “At this point, there's
simply no possible future that averts dislocation. Billions of people will have to dramatically change the way they live or the world will change dramatically or we will see some combination of the two. My experience reporting on climate change, which now spans almost twenty years, has convinced me that the most extreme out-comes are, unfortunately, among the most likely. As the warnings have grown more dire and the consequences of warming more obvious, emissions have only increased that much faster.”

A few more good quotes:
  • “If our way of life is ending nature, it is not too radical to talk about transforming our way of life.” 
  • “Life is precarious, and you can crush it by holding on too tightly, or you can love it…Even in a world of dying, new lives co tiniest to be born.”
  • [On managed retreat], “not everybody is going to live where they are now and continue their way of life, and that is a terrible, and emotional reality to face.”
  • “Climate change is not so much a reduction in productivity as a redistribution, and it’s one in which the poorest people on earth get hit the hardest and the rich world benefits.” 

It’s hard to finish this collection and not walk away sensing the doom and gloom is already on the horizon. I suppose the only respite is we just have to keep moving forward because there is no other way. Finding the solace in the next day. And if we can make things a little better along the way then let’s do it wholeheartedly. 

shelby1994's review

Go to review page

challenging informative slow-paced

4.0

 
The Fragile Earth: Writing from the New Yorker on Climate Change 

“Like the future, dystopia is already here. It's just unevenly distributed “ 

This behemoth of a collection of New Yorker essays from the last 50 years has something for everyone, if you’re patient enough to dig for it. The essays here bounce from climate change science, geology, environmentalism, and animal welfare, to urban development, the use of weather in literature, and wildfire containment tactics.  Like most collections that bring together different authors, some of the entries will leave you feeling colder than others – in my case, the first several chapters were borderline Ambien-like, and it wasn’t until reading “Writer in the Storm,” that I gave it my full attention.  

I think most people would benefit from picking up this collection and going straight towards the pieces that align with their interests.  As a starting point, these were my favorite ones: 

-       “Writer in the Storm” (Weather in Literature) 
-       “The New Harpoon” (Whale Hunting; Native Traditions v. Development) 
-       “The Sixth Extinction” (Animal Extinction) 
-       “The End of the World” (Jonathan Franzen’s Trip to Antarctica) 
-       “The Day the Great Plains Burned” (Coverage of the Starbuck Fire) 
-       “Green Manhattan” (The Environmental Benefits of Being a City Girl) 

Also, this interview with the editor of the book was very informative and gives you an idea of what the New Yorker was trying to achieve with this publication: 

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/apr/18/david-remnick-new-yorker-editor-no-vaccine-for-climate-change-fragile-earth 

cboll's review

Go to review page

challenging informative sad slow-paced

3.75

pearseanderson's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Some good stuff! But mostly this made me sad at how slow (but sweeping) the conversation on the climate crisis has evolved through the years. Like, goddamn, we needed to have such a more intense conversation in the 80s about the crisis because #ExxonKnew for decades! That shouldn't've been the beginning of the climate talks, it should have been the middle. I'm sure that a lot of these fire-based articles here will feel the same very soon. Australia, California, they've changed so much in fire regimes since this essay collection started collectin' pieces! Fuck! I think I need to read more specialized pieces, but this was good to catch up on -- see where the New Yorker is at generally.

thebookgirl's review

Go to review page

challenging hopeful informative inspiring reflective relaxing sad slow-paced

4.25

xjuliaaaaaax's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark informative reflective slow-paced

4.0

jmac17's review

Go to review page

dark emotional informative sad tense

5.0