Scan barcode
hannah_deverall's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 stars.
The beginning of this book was amazing. The first several chapters were well-researched and provided as much certainty as possible for things with little fossil evidence and happened millions of years ago. However, as the chapters progressed, their quality went down. Steeply. The final few chapters I found were almost complete speculation, and the author came to no conclusions whatsoever. Which is fine. Science does that a lot. But it sure does not make for a good read.
Personally, I think that this author dealt with the gender-diverse topics that invariably come up when talking about female bodies - as well as a cis-woman who does not seem to be deeply entrenched in the LGBTQ+ community. She generally uses terminology the right way (there was only one notable exception to this, and that was with a simply more outdated - rather than offensive - term that I have noticed older people tend to use much more. She is also very clear from the beginning that in most cases in her book the term 'woman' will refer to a cis-woman, simply because not much research has been done on the bodies of both trans men and women. Sooo much more research needs to be done in that area by the way, and reading this book made me realise just how little we know about gender-diverse bodies. Overall, it was really refreshing to read a feminist book about sex that was not written by a TERF. It has given me hope in humanity again.
One of the really positive things that stuck with me and was totally worth reading through all the slog at the end of the book was the fact that female bodies are not constantly preparing themselves to be pregnant just to make babies, which is what is commonly taught in sex ed classes around the world. Instead, a much more likely situation is that the body knows that it physically can get pregnant - not that it should - and decides to prepare so that if pregnancy did occur, they would not die.
The beginning of this book was amazing. The first several chapters were well-researched and provided as much certainty as possible for things with little fossil evidence and happened millions of years ago. However, as the chapters progressed, their quality went down. Steeply. The final few chapters I found were almost complete speculation, and the author came to no conclusions whatsoever. Which is fine. Science does that a lot. But it sure does not make for a good read.
Personally, I think that this author dealt with the gender-diverse topics that invariably come up when talking about female bodies - as well as a cis-woman who does not seem to be deeply entrenched in the LGBTQ+ community. She generally uses terminology the right way (there was only one notable exception to this, and that was with a simply more outdated - rather than offensive - term that I have noticed older people tend to use much more. She is also very clear from the beginning that in most cases in her book the term 'woman' will refer to a cis-woman, simply because not much research has been done on the bodies of both trans men and women. Sooo much more research needs to be done in that area by the way, and reading this book made me realise just how little we know about gender-diverse bodies. Overall, it was really refreshing to read a feminist book about sex that was not written by a TERF. It has given me hope in humanity again.
One of the really positive things that stuck with me and was totally worth reading through all the slog at the end of the book was the fact that female bodies are not constantly preparing themselves to be pregnant just to make babies, which is what is commonly taught in sex ed classes around the world. Instead, a much more likely situation is that the body knows that it physically can get pregnant - not that it should - and decides to prepare so that if pregnancy did occur, they would not die.
turidt's review against another edition
challenging
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
4.0
bmpicc's review against another edition
challenging
informative
inspiring
medium-paced
4.0
Some sections felt more evidence based than other, but it was still all fascinating. Particular points of interest for me included learning that males and females react differently to pain medications, and the how & why behind the evolution of reproduction for some animals; I'm looking at you mallard ducks. The female body is seriously incredible.
Graphic: Misogyny, Rape, and Pregnancy
Minor: Infertility and Miscarriage
jocie_roller's review against another edition
4.5
This book is fascinating. It offers an alternative perspective on the driving forces of evolution, speciation, and the development of human civilization by summarizing biological, archeological and anthropological research that supports the thesis that the reproductive and offspring rearing characteristics of mammalian female bodies can explain the ways our human bodies and societies function today. This is a contrast to the typical story of human speciation which emphasizes the biological evolution of hunting, self-defense, and physical domination and minimizes the uniquely female contributions to our evolution. For example, while hunting, farming, and fire making tools are typically considered vital for survival and the building of societies, Bohannon argues that the development of ancient genecology and fertility treatments were more important milestones for early humans and other hominids species as this is what allowed the continuation of a genetic line that made the hunting, gathering, and shelter-making worthwhile evolutionarily.
The text is scientific - I highly recommend reading by audiobook to parse the density of information - but Bohannon returns to an imagined "Eve" story with each chapter to describe each ancestor species that originated a particular female sex characteristic and relate it to our human female experience which lightens the style without compromising the science.
While absolutely a feminist perspective; feminist-humanist social theory this book is not. It's subsintabely a book on evolutionary biology, not sociology or gender politics. This book is far less concerned with arguing that women are equally adept at navigating a corporate boardroom or handling physical labor. It embraces physical differences between mammalian sexes but argues that female bodies have the physical differences they do because they were vitally important to getting our species to a point where our bodies can even comprehend complex social arrangements such as gender and patriarchy. It analyzes generalized truths about female bodies such as why are they smaller than male bodies? Why do they carry more fat? Why are their voices higher pitched? Why do they live longer than men? The answer to most of these questions is because female bodies evolved to divert a portion of their biological energies toward reproduction - but reproduction was absolutely essential is what allowed for humans to evolve into the type of animal that can write feminist literature and argue about gender equity and human dignity.
And a note on human gender: While this book is centered around the concept of "biological sex" (sometimes a transphobic dog-whistle when applied to humans), I did not find the substance of this book transphobic or even trans-exclusionary. Multiple times, the author created space to acknowledge the existence of transgender, nonbinary, intersex, and queer people and clarify when she was referring to scientific, biological sex characteristics, and when she was referring to gender characteristics. She used trans and genderqueer individuals as interesting case studies comparing the relative influence of biological sex characteristics and constructed gender socialization as well as considering the effects of sex hormones when produced by a person's body versus when acquired by a external prescription. She also acknowledging that transness is a relatively new field of study to an evolutionary biology, but one that deserves more study.
Ultimately, Bohannon chose a potentially controversial topic for an intersectional feminist to write about and ultimately did it well. The evolution that resulted in the human female body is fascinating and relevant to modern social topics such as reproductive freedom, gendered and sexual violence, economic and social gender equity, healthcare, childcare, and so many others. She uses biological sex not as a weapon to divide socialized gender discrepancies, but rather as an argument that female bodies have done more than their share of the evolutionary innovation that have resulted in a fully conscious, creative, diverse species capable of transcending our basic sex differences to pursue a future of our own individualized sexual, reproductive, and gendered destiny.
The text is scientific - I highly recommend reading by audiobook to parse the density of information - but Bohannon returns to an imagined "Eve" story with each chapter to describe each ancestor species that originated a particular female sex characteristic and relate it to our human female experience which lightens the style without compromising the science.
While absolutely a feminist perspective; feminist-humanist social theory this book is not. It's subsintabely a book on evolutionary biology, not sociology or gender politics. This book is far less concerned with arguing that women are equally adept at navigating a corporate boardroom or handling physical labor. It embraces physical differences between mammalian sexes but argues that female bodies have the physical differences they do because they were vitally important to getting our species to a point where our bodies can even comprehend complex social arrangements such as gender and patriarchy. It analyzes generalized truths about female bodies such as why are they smaller than male bodies? Why do they carry more fat? Why are their voices higher pitched? Why do they live longer than men? The answer to most of these questions is because female bodies evolved to divert a portion of their biological energies toward reproduction - but reproduction was absolutely essential is what allowed for humans to evolve into the type of animal that can write feminist literature and argue about gender equity and human dignity.
And a note on human gender: While this book is centered around the concept of "biological sex" (sometimes a transphobic dog-whistle when applied to humans), I did not find the substance of this book transphobic or even trans-exclusionary. Multiple times, the author created space to acknowledge the existence of transgender, nonbinary, intersex, and queer people and clarify when she was referring to scientific, biological sex characteristics, and when she was referring to gender characteristics. She used trans and genderqueer individuals as interesting case studies comparing the relative influence of biological sex characteristics and constructed gender socialization as well as considering the effects of sex hormones when produced by a person's body versus when acquired by a external prescription. She also acknowledging that transness is a relatively new field of study to an evolutionary biology, but one that deserves more study.
Ultimately, Bohannon chose a potentially controversial topic for an intersectional feminist to write about and ultimately did it well. The evolution that resulted in the human female body is fascinating and relevant to modern social topics such as reproductive freedom, gendered and sexual violence, economic and social gender equity, healthcare, childcare, and so many others. She uses biological sex not as a weapon to divide socialized gender discrepancies, but rather as an argument that female bodies have done more than their share of the evolutionary innovation that have resulted in a fully conscious, creative, diverse species capable of transcending our basic sex differences to pursue a future of our own individualized sexual, reproductive, and gendered destiny.
raealityreads's review against another edition
Just kind of bored with the topic and the premise of the book it digs deeper into the science and the history than I was interested in and a lot of the surface level information I already knew.
christine_alexandra's review against another edition
funny
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
5.0