Adorable story about crayons who are putting on a play/story. Great intro to mysteries for young kids.

Quite silly, but its fun and the idea of how one thing can be turned into another has great arts integration potential.

All the charm of "Red" scribbled with laughter. Love it.

With a bigger group, this might be a little hard to read aloud and keep everyone focused, but I still LOVE this book. So funny, so creative, so cute, and the ending made me laugh out loud. Michael Hall is a gem.

I love a picture book that breaks the 4th wall.

The illustrations are wonderful and the story is fun. Imaginative, creative, enjoyable, and worthwhile read.

I loved the twist at the end! The rest of it....I didn't connect with very much.

Very fun! Meta picture books are my jam. And I liked how the missing crayons show up at the end

This picture book has been cancelled. The crayons in the story are saddened that the picture book won’t be happening. After all, they have costumes and were going to tell an amazing story. But now that someone is actually reading the cancelled story, they may as well tell the reader exactly why the picture book has ended. It is all because of the horrible scribble that suddenly interrupted the story. They tried to clean the page, but the scribble just got larger and larger. It was out of control and everyone was so disturbed by it that they forgot to tell Frankencrayon that something was wrong. So when the crayons playing him entered on Page 22, they ran right into the scribble. It would take some quick thinking and fast action to save the story.

Hall has such a playful approach to picture books that one never quite knows what sort of story they are heading into. This book is great fun from the set up of the “cancellation” to the crayons in costumes. It is clever and humorous with exactly the sort of humor that preschoolers adore. Children will not be scared by anything here thanks to the use of crayons and the horror being a scribble on the page. This one reads aloud beautifully, filled with voices of the pencil, the crayons, and even one evil scribbler.

The cut paper collage pops on each page, the crayons bright with their colors and delightful in their different sizes after clearly having been merrily colored with for some time. The pointy pencil too somehow has its own personality. The solution that Frankencrayon comes up with is exactly what children would think of and adds to the visual appeal of the book.

This funny picture book is perfect to share aloud with a group of preschoolers who may love to do their own transformations of scribbles into something more friendly. Appropriate for ages 3-5.

Cybils nominee for best fiction picture book. More later.