pershephone's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Chiar o carte bine scrisa,nu o poti numi doar o reflectie asupra creatiilor lor si sa intre prea mult in detalii despre fiecare colectie,dar nici doar o biografie statica.
desi am ras noi de miss de pe spatele copertei a stiut sa gaseasca un balans dintre cele doua
Am o oarecare cunostiinta despre cei doi (Mcqueen in special)insa,tot am ramas captivata si am inteles mai bine unele lucruri,dar consider ca este acceptabila de urmarit si de cineva cu zero cunostiinte
Just another Mcqueen lover trough and trough

hamster02's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny reflective sad medium-paced

4.25

frozensnowshoe's review

Go to review page

4.25

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I was engrossed in every little detail. Honestly, this book could have been 600+ pages and I would still want more. It is interesting that the book was published in 2015 and ended the book not knowing the future of Galliano. If the 2024 met gala was any indication, Galliano's past antisemitic comments have been completely forgiven because every single celeb was in Galliano.

I have a bias towards McQueen, even though he could obviously be a pompous, misogynistic, ass, I felt like the author also favored McQueen over Galliano. It felt like Thomas was gently guiding readers to compare the two and put McQueen in a slightly better light, if ever so slightly.

nrmdova's review

Go to review page

emotional inspiring reflective medium-paced

4.5

BIBLE. audiobook only. 

1outside's review

Go to review page

dark informative sad medium-paced

4.0

On the one hand I understand why the author decided to put these two designers into one book, but just as I felt somehow disgusted by fashion people mourning Galliano's demise from Dior as a result of his profoundly unsubtle antisemitic rants in a similar way they mourned McQueen's death by suicide, I kind of...dislike the author pretty much doing the same. Early in the book, we see some seeds of why a person out of their mind on drugs/booze might slide into antisemitism (Catholic mother, early childhood growing up on a Jewish street in Gibraltar, first boyfriend being Jewish), but it' never followed up on thus when the book gets around to the incident. 

Anyway, it's a good book, a very good book, lots of information. Perhaps a bit too much, the marathon of "and then he did this collection and then he did that collection" with periods of fucked up behaviour In-between can be a bit monotonous, but perhaps that's the point.

Anyway, McQueen is pretty much one of my favourite artists. I knew the general overview but definitely not the level of (mainly sad) detail if his life and work I'm glad I read this....even though it made for a shit bed read. Book reading is my offline time, and I had to look up collections every two pages, hence why it took me (IMO) way too long to get through the book. Anyway, a solid 4/5

noticiasdelimperio's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative fast-paced

3.75

 it's been a ride to read this as condé nast has rolled out a series of efforts to bring john galliano back into the public eye and possibly into a more prestige house than maison margiela. it shows the initial stages of a process that is unfolding right now, in the case of john galliano's career and image rehabilitation, but also in the production of runway fashion as spectacle ultimately geared towards sales of more affordable mass-produced luxury items, the rise of the fashion conglomerate and the evolution of the figure of the designer into that of the creative director. 

as a double biography it's sort of episodic and formulaic in its structure, but i suppose that's due to the sheer amount of information that has to be condensed in one book. the downside to that is that whatever reflection or insight it has on mcqueen and galliano as people or participants in their relationships with the people around them are concise to the point of feeling somewhat shallow, and its eventual conclusion as well as thomas' take on the phenomenon that their two stories describe seem rushed. 

that said, the information in itself is interesting and a total blast to read with a tab of vogue runway open, and just the accumulation of it shows the effect of a large-scale economic process on the actual bodies of the people participating in it; i just wish this was explored further. 

dmknyc's review

Go to review page

challenging dark informative inspiring reflective sad tense medium-paced

4.25

horrorclassics's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional informative reflective sad slow-paced

3.5

beq3's review

Go to review page

2.0

The first half was quite enjoyable, reading about their background, their time at Central Saint Martins, early shows, breakthroughs, muses etc. But once they were respectively ensconced at Givency and Dior it all just became so so dull. Page after page after page describing clothes. You get weary trying to picture them and you can't look everything up on google. And the men themselves were just such unpleasant arrogant arses. And what they did barely useful if we're honest. Mostly the clothes seemed to be completely unwearable and the shows used to drive sales of perfumes and belts. So not only dull, but cynical and depressing.

There are some pictures at the end. It's hard to understand why there aren't more and why they are not scattered through the book alongside relevant text, at least in the kindle edition. It would have made it all a lot more enjoyable.

So I'd recommend only for hard core fashion fans. I'd only a passing interest really.

jderv's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

really interesting, well-written, does a nice job a dividing the 2 men's stories throughout... it goes into a LOT of detail on the seasonal fashion shows and specific fashion details - almost too much detail for me but I'm sure that true followers of fashion will find all the details really interesting. A very good read