I took me awhile to get into the book but it had a good premise and plot, i’ve always loved peter pan and wendy and I had high hopes for this book.

I wouldn’t say I was disappointed but it wasn’t what I hoped for, the shadow being the villain was brilliant and could very much be terrifying. A shadow that feeds on fear and everything bad in the world that takes children is brilliant. Though the way he was defeated very much seemed cartoonish and way to easy.


The relationship between Wendy and Peter was sweet but felt rushed even for characters that had feelings for each other forever. Peter losing his abilities because he wanted to stay with wendy makes sense.

I think the ending and climax disappointed me most, but the rest of the book was very good. Am I upset about peter and wendy? Yes but in this case i’ll let it pass since the Darlings had already lost so much. Though I’ve always wanted peter and wendy to end up together, i sadly say I think they will always be that doomed romance.

The death of John and Michael was tragic and Mr davies was a good Plottwist, but idk I had hoped for something else.

This book had plenty of potential but just did not follow through