reread 31/12/22 - I feel much better about this book after some time away to hype it less in my head. I loved revisiting jack and jill and their relationship and I would still love more from them. In this it does feel like their story has come to a close so I doubt we'll see more from them, but a girl can dream! 5/5

Not my favourite of the series, I think with Down Among the Sticks and Bones being my favourite, I hyped this up too much in my head. I wanted there to be more action, considering this is set around a quest, but I found there was a lot of standing around talking, especially for a novella. 
I still really loved it though, and I'd love to go and re-read this series in chronical order for Jack and Jill's story (Down Among, Every Heart, Come Tumbling).
4/5 stars!