My toxic trait is I enjoyed this more than the original. Probably because Louis and his whining about good and evil gets really old really fast. Claudia on the other hand is a tragic antiheroine if there’s such a thing. 

I don’t think you’re really getting anything new here though so it’s probably more of a novelty than anything else, you know? If you read the novel you know ever beat of this and Claudia in her own words adds little to nothing to it. The artwork is very pretty at times though.