If I had to choose my favorite book of the trilogy, I’d choose this one. While Peter Kavinsky is the popular, athletic kid that most girls swoon over, I was kind of in love with John Ambrose McClaren – intelligent, thoughtful, ambitious. He had more in common with Lara Jean too! Peter & his ex Genevieve were so obnoxious in this book, if anything Peter remains annoying in all 3 books but he was the most irritating in this book. So, who will she end up with? It’s cute, sweet and brings back memories of high school all over again. As Stormy would probably say, a girl should always have choices.