Scan barcode
A review by the_jesus_fandom
Forest of Scarlet by Tara Grayce
4.0
Overall, a nice book! 4 stars not necessarily for great quality but for great entertainment
What I liked:
- I love the Scarlet Pimpernel! So this was a fun twist. I actually liked this story almost better than the Scarlet Pimpernel series, cause Chauvelin was way stronger in this one.
- I am such a sucker for hostage stories
- Brigid's banter with her enemy was very funny
- This line goes hard:
What I disliked:
- There was a lot of comma abuse. Example: "grand, garden palace" It's just a grand garden palace, no COMMA!
- A lot of unsubtle telling instead of showing. This unsubtlety goes for a lot of the jokes as well ("stole what we have rightfully stolen") On the other hand, unsubtle jokes can be very funny.
- There's a moment where the Head Librarian waves at Brigid dismissively and then she mentions he has become like her granddad, which was a bit of a weird incongruity.
- We get it, Munch has a "dignified widow's peak"
- The "plot twist" was predicted in the text. But I loved it anyway.
- At one point, Brigid is defeated. She has very negative thoughts.
- WHY DID SHE
- Do I like or dislike the way they dealt with the kissing at the end? Was it realistic or just gross? idk, i've never kissed anyone
Other stuff:
- This book will reference earlier books, but you can read it first and still get everything.
- A side character is called Percy.
- This is another one of those "guess what? women can be beautiful AND smart!" books
What I liked:
- I love the Scarlet Pimpernel! So this was a fun twist. I actually liked this story almost better than the Scarlet Pimpernel series, cause Chauvelin was way stronger in this one.
- I am such a sucker for hostage stories
- Brigid's banter with her enemy was very funny
Spoiler
How did she stuff paper into her pocket without him noticing though? I get its magic but you'll steal hear the rustle- This line goes hard:
Spoiler
Take the mercy, Lord Chauvlyn, and enjoy a taste of the things you named foolish.
What I disliked:
- There was a lot of comma abuse. Example: "grand, garden palace" It's just a grand garden palace, no COMMA!
- A lot of unsubtle telling instead of showing. This unsubtlety goes for a lot of the jokes as well ("stole what we have rightfully stolen") On the other hand, unsubtle jokes can be very funny.
- There's a moment where the Head Librarian waves at Brigid dismissively and then she mentions he has become like her granddad, which was a bit of a weird incongruity.
- We get it, Munch has a "dignified widow's peak"
- The "plot twist" was predicted in the text. But I loved it anyway.
- At one point, Brigid is defeated. She has very negative thoughts.
Spoiler
Then it turns out it was a part of her plan. So why was she having all these defeated thoughts?- WHY DID SHE
Spoiler
KISS CHAUVLYN????- Do I like or dislike the way they dealt with the kissing at the end? Was it realistic or just gross? idk, i've never kissed anyone
Other stuff:
- This book will reference earlier books, but you can read it first and still get everything.
Spoiler
Except who on Earth Claudius is, the BIG VILLAIN. And he wasn't even mentioned in the Blackbeard story, so genuinely... who is he?- A side character is called Percy.
Spoiler
And Brigid is disguised as his wife!- This is another one of those "guess what? women can be beautiful AND smart!" books