stephenie meyer said this will no longer be a love triangle because i will make jacob so unlikeable that you can't be on his team. no but for real, i love jacob in new moon but his character just gets ruined in this book. he is so unbelievably manipulative to bella and knows it (yet doesn't feel any shame about it). both of their kisses made me want to cry because on one he just forces himself onto her and the other he threatens to get himself killed. that was my main takeaway from this book tbh. still 4 stars, but just for nostalgic reasons!