This is a fine book. I was really excited to dive into a thrilling world of alchemy and magic, but I think I had different expectations than what this book really is - that’s on me, though, I should have read the description better. 

The overall story of this book is intriguing, and I enjoyed the action scenes that were full of detail and imagery. I loved the characters and reading such a queerly diverse cast! (Again, this is me not reading the description well enough) I often felt that the romance took over the fantasy/alchemy plot and really placed those on the back burner. I would have liked to learn more about alchemy in New Anglia. 

Overall, this book is fine. I think it will be enjoyed by readers who like heavy romance mixed with their fantasy plots. I will also say that some of this book’s romance scenes skirt the line between young adult and new adult, so if you are someone who is planning to recommend this book to readers, I would definitely keep that in mind.