3.5 plot but it gets a 4 because the spice was some of the best I have EVER read. I liked the plot and the conflicts because I found them to be believable. However, I felt conflicts were resolved too easily. 

I do not think parents would so quickly get over the idea that their daughter is dating not one, but TWO men almost twice her age. Add on top of that that Carl is Katie’s boss? The power imbalance here is crazy.

I also found the resolution of the conflict between the two sisters to be unbelievable.

There was so much deep seeded resentment and I do not believe that they could get over it simply by smiling and complimenting each other a little bit. I understand that the big event that happens at the end furthers her relationship with her sister, but I think there was more that needed to be addressed.

Also resentment does not go away so easily.

The age gap between the two MMCs and Katie was a little unsettling. On top of that, the fact that they wanted a baby SO quickly when she’s literally in her early twenties makes me feel gross.