Between a 3 and 4, but I bumped it up to a 4 bc I really like the story and characters. What was pulling it down, for me, was 1) alternating 1st person POV which I loathe unreservedly and 2) approximately 100 pages was Jas being completely obnoxious about pushing Dev away/refusing help which was about 50 pages too many, in my opinion. But I really loved Jas and Dev as characters together, plus all the secondary characters (Blake and Shawn, Nikki and Pete, the parents) and how real the world around them felt.