I mean it is a Twilight novel and I've always found Edward and Bella a bit annoying with their never-ending brooding inner dialogues and I could never get behind the Instalove BUT... I really enjoyed the missing parts we didn't get in Twilight, to see more of the other Cullens who I really love and the way Edward's mind reading is handled is pretty cool. I mostly had fun reading it, it brought me a lot of nostalgia. For me it was worth the read.