I did not like it as much as the first one. I think it was because Logan was being a poop and did not change until later in the story. Also I cringed a little when she would act like a total girl when Logan was around, but maybe that is just the effect he has on all the girls, so I shouldn't be too hard. It was pretty obvious who was really going to be the villain attacking Gwen in this book so the mysterious part kind of failed a little bit in my opinion. ;)Other than that I liked it a lot of it was fun, entertaining and full of adventure.