This book was absolutely amazing!!! You can never really go wrong with historical fiction. The premise, the way both timelines connected, and to know the author’s inspiration for the novel came from a single photograph. She used a work of fiction to give life to a person with an unknown history and an untold story. I think everything was perfectly executed. It’s a bit lengthy and kind of a slow-burn but the build up was well worth it.

I found the book to be both a heartbreaking yet enriching experience. It’s one of those books you didn’t know you needed. The pacing was up and down but the way it was structured and how the author wove together the timelines it gave the book a suspenseful edge.

While we see Celestine’s life told from his perspective it was Lowra’s timeline that helped fill in the missing pieces. The situation with Agatha inviting Celestine into her bedroom let me know where the book was headed. It also made Lowra’s connection to Celestine and the attic more clear.

Overall, this was a great read. The characters were fleshed out vividly. Celestine was a very humble and brave character when faced with difficulty. I couldn’t stand Agatha or Lowra’s stepmother. I never felt Sir Richards had pure intentions when it came to Celestine. It makes you wonder what his fate would have been had his mother not sent him away with Sir Richard. Lowra and Celestine both had traumatic childhood experiences that had me deeply invested. I don’t think you can really read this without being moved. Definitely a book I recommend!!!