2.5 stars

I enjoyed this little book somewhat, but for me the cons outweighed the pros. See below.


Pros:
- fast paced
- quick read
- likable characters (for the most part)

Cons
- it was very unrealistic (I can’t imagine half of the plot actually occurring in Victorian England) - this one counts for a lot when dealing with historical fiction that isn’t touted as having fantasy or sci fi elements
- I wanted more Sherlock Holmesian references or more characters suitable to Holmes stories
- The ease with which Peter and Dora shared their secrets... they’re called secrets for a reason but apparently Peter and Dora (as well as a handful of other characters) missed the memo
- Too. Many. Letters!!!
- the actual mystery (the blackmailed letters) that spurred on the second mystery (the kidnapped Lady) was never satisfactorily explained

I could probably keep going, but this gives a taste of my dissatisfaction. Or perhaps more than a taste...