These are more my thoughts than a review. ********

Like many others have said there are things about this book I absolutely loved and some things I didn’t quite like. The ending was a bit rushed but just like many other books and movies we all have seen, it all fits but we needed better closer and needed a bit more time. I wish the magic of scents were used throughout the entire book instead of thick in part 1, half the amount in part 2, and extremely lacking in part 3. The main character was a bit weak and had me irritated that she rarely stood up for herself. I will admit that the book isn’t as predictable and that made me happier and liked the book more. There were some slow moments that made me want to give up reading but I am so happy I didn’t stop.