thank you to st. martin’s press, wednesday books, and netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

another week passes and we have another raving review that may never see the light of day. but as i write this (a bit later than i planned but still possibly much much earlier than anyone will see this) i fondly think back to my time reading this gem of a book.

after reviewing edward underhill’s debut last year and absolutely adoring it, i had high hopes for their sophomore novel and he sure did not disappoint. this story of two teens in marching band having shenanigans across new york city on thanksgiving eve was the story i never knew i truly needed. not even discussing the characters yet, the actual plot of two teens separating from their high school groups going on essentially a scavenger hunt across the city, all while coming to terms with their feelings, their identities, it was peak 2000s rom-com energy for me. and if it wasn’t marketed as that, it definitely should be.

getting to follow abby and leo’s live in this 2 day snippet was truly a highlight. it’s always so funny to read about people visiting the city i grew up around for the first time. experiencing the overwhelming energy that is NYC. and underhill depicted their adventures so well. showcasing some iconic and popular landmarks, up to the quintessential experiences like the hole-in-the-wall pizza places. were the native new yorkers a tad too nice to our out of towners… yes. but we let it slide in the name of romcom movie magic! i think overall, it was an honest look at the mayhem of the city, even (and especially really) before a major holiday.

i loved abby and leo so much. seeing them see each other, fully. accepting their queer identities. having this whirlwind romance and adventure. it was truly just so heartwarming. all i want is to read about them in college, anytime after the books ends really. their relationship is just so precious.