Utterly delightful. The art was so fun and pleasant to look at, the story was straight-forward but with several little twists I didn't expect, and while it was an original story, the way Jane used her wits to overcome each new trial reminded me a lot of classic fairy tales or folktales. 

Shaving off a sliver of a star just because of one minor event midway that confused me and felt a little deus-ex-machina-y since I didn't feel it had been properly established earlier

when the giant fish snags her shawl in its teeth and the shawl seems to burst into flames; when I looked back through the book the only thing I could find was that the shawl was magically meant to keep her warm at the bottom of the ocean, so I /guess/ that's supposed to be where the fire comes from? But it was pretty unclear and seemed to happen out of nowhere as far as I could tell

, but other than that I thought everything fit together really well, and it was just such a fun and enjoyable book. Definitely my favorite of Vera Brosgol's works so far.