Shay and Noah had such a cute relationship. I know this is always what happens with fake dating - they start developing feelings but talks themselves out of thinking the other person does too. And I love fake dating!!! But this got on my nerves. It was obvious from the start that Noah was in love with Shay. Despite his grumpiness and scowls, girl he offered marriage and then literally started acting like your husband. And when yall finally started hooking up, you still didn't think he was all in?!?! 

Shay had such a good character arc. She was really broke down by the break-up, and by the end she saw what a POS the ex-fiance was. I REALLY REALLY wish Noah would've punched him, especially after putting hands on Shay. 

I feel like we could've learned more abut Noah. All we hear about his past is that he was quiet and wanted to get out of the town. I think we learned more about his sister than him. I wish we had a glimpse into their friendship earlier, instead of near the end with the letters. We got an idea of who Shay was as a teen, but he was sorely missing and it would've gave Noah a bit more depth.

Noah was a little freak so I quite enjoyed the spice 3/5🌶