This was more of 3.5 than 4, but closer to that than just a 3.

I enjoyed this book, and can say I didn't see the twist coming. But the twist didn't shock me, it was just like "oh, that explains a little bit". It wasn't a big shocker!!

Storyline flowed well, and was written in a wonderful way. I liked that I could learn first hand about Charity's story as well as Willows.