A review by obscurepages
Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir

5.0

Gideon the Ninth is weird, funny, brutal, and captivating! Filled with sword fights, skeletons, old and dangerous magic, nuns and priests, weird planets, and lesbian necromancers, this book is unbelievably unique and edgy.

Peculiar writing style
The writing style can take a while to get used to (pretty sure there are run-on sentences, sentences that are too long for me ((which can be tiring to the eyes)), and some fancy words here and there), but once I got going, I realized that the author has this peculiar writing style and it definitely adds to the uniqueness of this book.

There was humor but there was also weirdly dark tales about the characters and the world. There was also something elegant in the candid descriptions of the skeletons, the bones, and the anatomy of a body. Some might find this gory, but I found it really interesting. The narration of the sword fights were awesome as well! Brutal yet so captivating as I read on.

Interesting characters + great enemies-to-lovers trope
The characters were truly interesting! Gideon Nav is the best cavalier the Ninth House has ever produced and I would gladly die for her. *cries* She was tough and amazing and I believe there is more to her backstory (I do hope the sequel contains more of it!). Harrowhark Nonagesimus, on the other hand, was confident and determined. She's an extraordinary necromancer

And yes, this book has one of my favorite romance tropes, enemies-to-lovers. And guys, let me tell you, the author did it so painfully and beautifully. There was hate (and not just for nothing, there was a reason), there was tension, there was a building of trust, there was the undeniable care for each other at the end. In conclusion, my heart ached, I am not even kidding.

In a way, the characterization here in Gideon the Ninth reminded me a lot of All for the Game. These characters, and not just Gideon and Harrow but the minor characters as well, will really take you on a journey and will have you rooting for them and will have you wanting for more.

Wild plot
Okay, imagine tributes from Hunger Games (but instead of districts they come from weird planets), and the arena is a Gothic castle with skeletons as servants, and the prize is immense power and immortality. And these tributes would have to solve puzzles and challenges to achieve the prize. Pretty simple right? What makes it so wild was the addition of unforeseen deadly events, brutal sword fights, plus secrets and revelations. There were certain plot twists in Gideon the Ninth that really made me pause and go back to see if what I read was real.

The first half of the story line can be dragging though. The main plot needed to be set up (introduction to the Ninth House, Gideon's disdain to her current life, Harrow's mission, how Gideon came to be the Ninth "cavalier"), and the world-building can be dense. The second half was where all the crazy things started to happen and it continued on until the end. I really loved reading through that second half!

Epic world-building
Gideon the Ninth has one of the most unique and complex fictional worlds I've ever had the pleasure to read about. The world-building was a captivating blend of fantasy and science fiction—a blend of dangerous magic and gods, and space and sword fights. It was weird and alluring without losing its Gothic aesthetic touch.

I'm actually so glad I have the House trading cards from Illumicrate because they contained more information about the different Houses and the people in Gideon the Ninth. When I saw them, I just knew this book would have an epic world-building, and I was right.

I give 4.5 stars for this book!

(This review was first posted on my blog.)