Scan barcode
A review by yellowbinge
Not The Same River by Fiction › Mystery & Detective › GeneralFiction / Mystery & Detective / GeneralFiction / Short Stories (single author)
challenging
emotional
mysterious
reflective
slow-paced
3.0
Publishing date: 03.08.2024
Thank you to NetGalley and Atmosphere Press for the ARC. My opinions are my own.
The book as a meal: A buffet with an interesting selection, but the food itself was mostly subpar or just okay
The book left me: A little burnt out
Negatives:
The extraordinary circumstances were not that extraordinary
Stories felt a little too long
Positives:
Stories are very distinct and different from each other
Very good writing
Features:
14 stories, mostly male POV, slice-of-life esque, trans representation
14 stories, mostly male POV, slice-of-life esque, trans representation
Why did I choose this one?
I was in my short story era when picking this up, and I once again judged the cover and thought it looked interesting because of that.
Pick-up-able? Put-down-able?
In between. I think I have put myself in a reading slump, and with these stories being the length that they are didn't help with that. Sometimes I could knock a couple stories out easily, other times I had to force myself to read. This might have turned my opinion a little against the book.
The stories are only about 30-40 minutes long if you read a little faster than most, but they felt longer.
What was the vibe and mood?
Since each story is different, the vibes and moods are different too. All I can say is that the recurring theme is not knowing enough about the situation and being helpless in doing anything about it.
Final ranking and star rating?
C tier, 3 stars. This was okay, it didn't wow me, it didn't make me cry, and I don't think it will stick around in my mind for long. Considering the fact that I was in a reading slump might make this rating unfair, and I might pick this up again later. I think this book fits better for those who really enjoy literary fiction, but I am more in the ballpark of surrealism. That's just the way the cookie crumbles.