This was a fun anthology to read with an interesting main theme. My overall rating for the anthology (average of all the story ratings) is a 3.8/5 Stars so I rounded up to 4 stars.

Individual Story Ratings (Asterisks denote my favorite stories):
Picking You by T. Ashleigh- 3/5 Stars
Cherry Ice by Addison Beck- 4/5 Stars*
The New Guy by Nicole Dykes- 4/5 Stars
Cherry Picking by Becca Jackson- 4/5 Stars
Until We Kiss by Loren Leigh- 4/5 Stars
Tucson Too Late by Sundae Leighton- 2.5/5 Stars
Demon in the Sheets by Lily Mayne-4/5 Stars
Always Been Me by Charlie Novak- 3.5/5 Stars
Rookie Moves by Jodi Oliver- 5/5 Stars*
Smoke and Holes by Cora Rose-3.5/5 Stars
All Shook Up by Sebastian Sharpe- 4/5 Stars
The to-Do List by Lark Taylor- 5/5 Stars*
The Sin Bin by Willow Thomas- 3.5/5 Stars