Scan barcode
A review by jedster247
Excellent Sheep: The Miseducation of the American Elite and the Way to a Meaningful Life by William Deresiewicz
3.0
Excellent analysis of the problems with higher education. Unfortunately his recommendations for change fall flat due to an idealized view of a liberal arts’ education.
The discussion on purpose, passion, vocation, and calling were helpful. And he was correct in suggesting the best job/life is not the one where you make the most money. His own career path is a great example of his point. Students don’t leave college as fully-formed professionals with their future perfectly planned out.
However, despite the fact he repeatedly insists he’s not religious, he suggests a liberal arts’ education is the vehicle to provide meaning and the discovery of your true self. In other words, this type of college functions as a temple/church with professors serving as cherished mentors/priests.
The discussion on purpose, passion, vocation, and calling were helpful. And he was correct in suggesting the best job/life is not the one where you make the most money. His own career path is a great example of his point. Students don’t leave college as fully-formed professionals with their future perfectly planned out.
However, despite the fact he repeatedly insists he’s not religious, he suggests a liberal arts’ education is the vehicle to provide meaning and the discovery of your true self. In other words, this type of college functions as a temple/church with professors serving as cherished mentors/priests.