Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
Wonderful! I did not realize when I started this that it was YA (bought about a year ago and shelved it, oops). I enjoyed it quite a bit anyway. I think my teen would love it too. It’s giving Howl’s Moving Castle vibes.
That was cute! I almost DNFed right away because, honestly, the writing isn’t exactly top notch. I’m glad I didn’t though. It was a great, light, fun read when I’ve been reading some pretty heavy topics lately. I was even invested enough to try to get the next book in the series, but my library doesn’t have it 🤷🏻♀️
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
This is one of those times that I wish I had reviewed this right away. I had a lot to say, and now it’s gone to the same place as my missing stray socks. I know I loved it. I know it went a lot deeper than a simple vampire story. This was also one of those rare times where I didn’t particularly like the main character, but I still found myself rooting for her and enjoying the book.
I should have paid more attention. I was looking for new homeschool mom “professional development” material, and this came up when I was searching for secular books. It’s clearly not. If you are Christian and are looking for a book with a heavy emphasis on faith, this is good. It started out great actually. But there was little practical application and much inspirational fluff. Since the inspirational fluff became increasingly faith-based, I found that not much of it really helped me personally. Your mileage may vary.
Full disclosure: I’ve made it halfway through, but set it back on the shelf for now.
I can’t decide how to feel about this book, but definitely heed all content warnings. It’s a heavy one. I appreciate some of the family dynamics, particularly between the sisters (up until a certain act that I can’t get on board with), but there’s not a while lot else that’s positive in this story. It’s extremely depressing. Granted, the subject matter is depressing at best and horrifying at worst. But it makes for a difficult read when it feels like there’s no point or there’s no hope. Maybe I need to read further, but a quick skim doesn’t reveal much either.
That’s not to say this is not well written. The fact that I am so affected is probably a good indicator of the writing quality. I just needed to set it aside for something lighter. Will update if and when I finish.
Well, I liked this more than my kids did. They thought it was alright and seemed interested enough while reading it, though. I liked seeing how much Esperanza grew over the course of her time in the worker’s camp—and the little hint of potential romance between her and her long-time friend, Miguel. They’ll have some work to do going from such different classes in Mexico to being basically at the same level in the U.S.
I work at a library, and I always try to read our state’s annual juvenile/teen book selections—although I do actually enjoy most YA anyway. This was my first YA pick for this year’s choices. It did not disappoint! Was it clearly intended for teens? Yes. Was it a great hook and unputdownable? Also yes!
First, I appreciated the diversity. I also enjoyed the author’s note detailing the research she has done into the real-life diversity of regency society. I kind of wish there was more to it than varied skin tones and the occasional sari, but I’ll grant that that wasn’t the focus of the plot.
I also liked the chemistry between MC and her love interest AND that it was sort of based on a shared history and sweet childhood together. I say sort of. Of course there was the deception with her assumed identity. One thing I really struggled to get past is that not one single person recognized her. This is explained, but not well enough in my opinion. Three years is a long time, especially to a teen, but it’s simply not long enough for someone to be so wholly unrecognizable. I thought, surely, her best friend and love had already figured it out and was playing along. He couldn’t possibly be that dumb… right? But alas, he is not actually perfect. This whole silly scenario lost the book a star for me.
I do wish there had been just a little more depth to Poppy’s character. Like perhaps a bit more background giving rise to her despicable behavior, aside from simply lacking a title and feeling jealous and petty. That’s basically her whole character in a nutshell. There was some real room for explanation and growth there, especially when all sh** hits the fan at the end.
Still. I was engrossed and thoroughly entertained. I think teens and young adults will really enjoy this one!