tuesday, august 8, 2023 there is something about this genre and subgenres that demands homage or reference to trope. iron widow seems to deny you any satisfaction in this regard. anytime you think you know where the story is going Zhao takes you somewhere else. its refreshing but also disruptive to the part of my brain that demands structure from my genre fiction
monday, july 24, 2023 i cant believe im done. im sad its over! i really have no major complaints. the serpent plot was a little weird and i half wish i wouldve gotten more catharsis with cardan and jude. but its not in their nature. otherwise, deliciously entertaining which is what i wanted and expected
“ […] and Baphen was uncomfortably reminded that some prophecies are fulfilled by the very actions meant to prevent them.”
friday, november 29, 2023 funnier than it has any right to be.
“A true Janian reply! Good angels be my guard! She comes from the other world—from the abode of people who are dead—and tells me so when she meets me alone here in the gloaming! If I dared, I’d touch you, to see if you are substance or shadow, you elf!”
thursday, june 15, 2023 saturday, july 22, 2023 (reread) I have no idea how to write a review for this. I cannot write coherent thoughts, I love it for all the world.
thursday, june 22, 2023 wow. blew all my expectations out of the water. everything I found at fault with the first book is suddenly gone with this one. I care about these characters SOOO much. I love Cardan and Jude. separately and together. and by god, does Holly Black know how to write tension. it's palpable and ancient. and she does the rare thing of balancing their hate and attraction on a razor's edge. I'm also realizing it's intensely gratifying to be in the head of someone who is such a cruel and conniving protagonist, but believing for all the world that what they're doing is for the greater good. Jude is a character for the ages.
wednesday, june 7, 2023 this is a book I primarily knew as a Tik Tok book. and with it came all of the implications of that, negative or otherwise. previously hailed as the pinnacle of enemies-to-lovers trope, I saw a booktube video that rectified this misconception and said it was a political intrigue story first with a romance subplot in the distant background.
I'm glad I went into this with the allure of false advertising dropped. I could enjoy it for what it was, instead of going in expecting something and being met with a story with different priorities.
the novel follows Jude, a human brought to the world of Faerie by the man who killed both of her parents. it’s best, in my opinion to go into the story not knowing much else.
I will tell you what it's not: this is not a romance novel. romance is an attribute, as it often is in young adult fiction—but it is not the central theme. In the foreground, The Cruel Prince is a political intrigue story among Fae. in the background, an enemies-to-lovers story that is not the main priority. if you go into it expecting only that, you will find this novel lacking.
as far as character work goes, it took a while for me to warm up to these characters. despite that, Jude, in particular, stands out to me as a pretty unique protagonist—she’s selfish and conniving without ever coming across as evil.
the story is supremely engaging with a power beyond my understanding. The moment I picked up the book I couldn’t put it down. I just had to finish it to see what would happen next. and that sense of total enthralled engagement remains until the end.
"If I cannot be better than them, I will become so much worse."