I skimmed some of the ones I wasn't vibing with so instead of a full ranking, here's the ones I really liked:
The Third Bear Felt very folktale, even with the Mord easter egg. Finding Sonoria I love places that don't exist. Predecessor This had Poe undertones. Fixing Hanover Def my second favorite. The maker meets its made. Shark God vs Octopus God Another myth type one. A little goofy at times honestly but I didn't mind. Three Days in a Border Town Easily my favorite. A moving city you can only catch in glimpses? You've sold me sir. Surgeon's Tale I mostly liked this because it felt like an alternate backstory to Locked Tomb series Jod if he somehow sucked in a different way.
R slur is used in Finding Sonoria. The character is an asshole so it's not unexpected but it does feel a bit out of left field. Do I think VanderMeer would write that in today? Probs not
So I'm on a quest to heal my relationship with straight romance because it used to cause me a horrendous amount of dysphoria, but now I understand I just wanted to be the boy the whole time lol.
This one is cute and gentle. I think the only reason I'm not rating it higher is because the love triangle started to get on my nerves. Every time there's a love triangle I'm like okay why don't you all just kiss about it? Or if I had a crush on a friend and they started dating someone I'd be like oh, good for you! And not be possessive and weird. But maybe I am just built different
The premise of a darker retelling of Rumpelstiltskin drew me to this book. The first chapter is really well done, and I can tell this author likely excels in his short stories (where he's clearly acclaimed).
After that, I could tell right away this is Dad Book Horror. There was an almost confusing nostalgia reading this as it felt like stealing Stephen King or Dean Koontz off my dad's shelf at a Way Too Young Age™. However, I'm an adult now.
The way women are talked about? Breasting Boobily.
People of color? Not great! Indigenous people specifically? Now we're bordering on HP Lovecraft levels of 'primitives worshipping an evil old god'.
All THAT aside (if you can possibly do so for a moment), the story is incredibly meandering? Building tension doesn't mean spending an entire chapter regaling us with the mc's children's lives. You can build tension in a way that's purposeful. The scares are good, I'll give him that, but come on now. This was published in 2012.