Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
It was fine. I wasn't really motivated to pick it up and was just reading it to finish it. I think the fact I've visited the witch stone in Dornoch, and seen a play about the women, and thus knew how their story ended removed any sense of suspense or jeopardy. I didn't care enough about the fate of the troupe for them to draw me in more. The writing is pretty basic and YA feeling and it rushed through the actual witch trial with minimal focus on the consequences or emotions of it. The modern part at the end was awful and twee.
Sylvia has two lovers, a sexy seaman called Charley and her cousin Philip who is a total A-hole. This one takes a while to get going and there is an unreasonable amount of whaling chat in the 1st half, although I did enjoy Sylvia's dad bragging about how he rode a whale in his youth. My man Napoleon is lurking in the backdrop and the press gang cause Sylvia no end of trouble with her men. Once it gets going there's all kinds of unbelievable coincidences and heartbreak and then, having made you hate Philip, Gaskell tries to redeem him. Sylvia may have forgiven him in the end but I never will! Not Gaskell's best but I did enjoy it, it made me cry, and for being over 400 pages I got through it pretty quick.
Graphic: Body horror, Child death, Death, Gore, Gun violence, Misogyny, Rape, Sexism, Sexual violence, Suicide, Torture, Violence, Blood, Medical content, Grief, Medical trauma, Suicide attempt, Death of parent, Murder, War, and Injury/Injury detail
Thanks very much to Serpents Tail for sending me a copy Jungle House to review. It's out on the 2nd November and I loved it. . I sped through this one in a couple of days, it's very fast paced, intriguing and well written. The relationship between Lena and Mother is so interesting and has all the hallmarks of a clingy mum; complicated relationship; coming of age type story but the mother is an AI who Lena relies on for all news and contact with the outside world. I loved that we didn't get any information on the outside world from anyone outside the bubble of Jungle House. I love an unreliable narrator and by the end I wasn't sure if the rebels even existed or were ever a threat. I had so many theories about where Isabella had gone (they were all wrong) and at times suspected every character both human and AI. Mother is precisely why I refuse to have a smart speaker! What if it evolves! As speculative fiction the world of Jungle House is wholly believable. But the book is equally about human relationships and whether we can really trust the people we rely on, even when they're all robots. I particularly enjoyed the chapters we got from each of the AI perspectives. Silvana and Alfonso's part in particularly was so endearing and I had a wee tear for them.